So, as I was finishing rounding the bend on Michael Bronski's A Queer History of the United States (15th Anniversary Edition, Revised and Expanded), I was surprised to find out I read the original printing back in 2018. As I finished this now reread, I reread the review I wrote then, and I find my opinion on the actual writing hasn't changed that much, although my perspective on what he's actually writing about has, largely due to reading more books on more "recent" gay history like David Carter's book on Stonewall or Peter Staley's mildly self serving account of Act Up or Cleve Jones's slightly less self serving autobiography or Christopher Isherwood's very campy but surprisingly insightful autobiography. He also is dealing with the problems of identifiers drifting to a point where properly labeling exactly how someone fits in the Queer Umbrella is kind of hard, a problem that plagued Randy P. Carter's Blossom of Bone.
See, there's two big issues with this volume, one of which is it's a survey, which means we don't get particularly in depth on topics, and the fact that he hesitates to make reports on anything that's occurred since 1990. (The original version cuts off in 1990, the new edition adds two chapters, one explaining why he's not trying to add much about what's happened since 1990, and one hitting highlights, but pointing out that in the immediacy of recent past, it's hard to see how big events now will fit into the weft and weave of queer history. I get that, I really do, particularly since the back and forth of Queer people getting rights is countered by people promptly trying to take them away or remove others, so it's literally like playing Wheel of Fortune on how much of what we have today can be taken away tomorrow.
He does do a better job of separating what he calls social purity from anarchy, although both lines cross into Queer society, whihc he also addresses when discussing thing like Mattachine vs Gay Liberation Front, and not getting as evil about it as some people did back in the 90's. (The first issue of OUT magazine I ever bought, amazingly on sale at the downtown IGA in my hometown that I screwed my courage up to buy, only to figure out that the cashier didn't give a shit had an article discussing Randy Shilts and Michelangelo Signorile throwing drinks at each other after calling each other "Fascist" and "Sell Out".) Reading the Stonewall history, one could make an argument the Anarchy side of the coin is what rebelled there, and the purity side made hay with it to bring queer respectability to the middle class.
On the other hand, having access to google for this read through did allow looking up images discussed in the book, which added some context to passages dealing with Depression art and WWII Art. (The first two are by Paul Cadmus, and got in trouble not for the homoerotic pictures, but because the US Navy thought it was suggesting Sailors visited prostitutes, the third is a War time advertisement featuring manly men to sell towels.)
Honestly, it's very dry, and it never really does more than dip a toe in to specfic people or events, but it will point you in the direction of places you can go seeking information you more want to get to know about, which is in and of itself a necessary function.



No comments:
Post a Comment