So, I somehow forgot Riley Sager released a book a year, so my reserve on The Unknown was a bit later than normal. Which is fine, while they're usually fun yarns, I'm never in a great hurry to be the first to read one.
The basic premise is this. Marin, in 2026, is a struggling actress with a facial cream commercial to her credit who gets invited to audition for a role in a horror movie with a hot director. Somehow, she gets the part, playing Daisy, a girl who, along with r other women vanished from an island in 1926. The script is based on Daisy's diary, the only proof that people were out there on the island in Vermont. (The legend goes 4 women were on the island with Mrs Semple, and left alone for a week, When the supply boat came in, no women were on the island, and all that they saw were dresses hanging in an old Oak tree.) Marin is cast as Daisy, who's one of the major characters in the screenplay, which ends on an ambiguous note as the last 5 pages of Daisy's diary were ripped out in 1926, so no one knows how it happened.
The director, Ronan Peters, has all of his cast and small crew out on the island to rehearse for a week, living as the characters, recreating scenes from the diary/screenplay. Which of course starts going wrong not long after the seance goes wild and Daisy's scary entity Azra comes through the table Ouija board. (The way it's described, there are letter tiles around the table, and a water glass serving as a planchette.) When the stuff starts happening, Ronan gives Marin the original diary, and events start repeating, as Marin starts seeing her dead sister's ghost again, and the other actresses start vanishing.
Without going into spoiler territory, about 2/3 of the way through, the majority of what's actually happening is revealed, and what should be a Hitchcock or Christie reveal instead devolves into William Castle directing Scooby Doo moment. There are still twists coming, but frankly, the initial denouement made those fairly unimpactful. Also, the diary, for the sake of the narrative is written in prose form, which kept throwing me out of narrative when Daisy is talking, since I have never read a diary written like an actual story, with verbatim dialog and not real judgement against the people the author is mad at.
This is not to say the book doesn't hold attention or read well, it's just suffering from the old Steven King curse, where the performance is great, but the landing doesn't impress.



